Skip to Content

The Wait is Finally Over!

Get Our Cookbook

BLT with Homemade Mayonnaise

  • Serves: 4
  • Prep Time: 10 min
  • Cook Time: 20 min
  • Calories: 635
two halves of a BLT with homemade mayonnaise stacked on top of each other on the counter Photography by Gayle McLeod

The BLT sandwich: You know it, you love it, but you haven’t truly experienced it until you try homemade. Look no further, we’ve got the best BLT recipe for you.

The BLT Sandwich: An American Classic

Name a more iconic sandwich, we’ll wait. The BLT is a heavy lifter on the menu of any self-respecting sandwich joint, deli, or diner. The oh-so-satisfying combination of crisp, salty bacon cut with the coolness of tomato and lettuce and the zestiness of mayonnaise puts it at the top of our sandwich list. It’s so simple, but when you put the perfect flavors together, you really don’t need much else!

toast, bacon, homemade mayonnaise, sliced tomatoes and lettuce on the counter for making BLTs with homemade mayonnaise

We’ve Got History with the BLT Sandwich

The BLT has been an American favorite for over a century! Making its first appearance in 1903 in the Good Housekeeping Everyday Cook Book, the BLT was originally named the “Club Sandwich.” This is thought to be because they were often served on US railways in “club” cars, hence the original “club sandwich” name. Back then it included a generous slice of turkey as well. It went from Club to BLT when waiters began writing down the order as “BLT”, standing for “bacon, lettuce, tomato”. And the rest is sandwich history!

a BLT being assembled surrounded by toast, bacon, homemade mayonnaise, sliced tomato and lettuce

What You’ll Need to Make the Perfect BLT

  • Homemade mayonnaise: Trust us on this one! Not only is it super easy to make, it really is the difference between a good BLT and the best BLT.

  • Bacon: Since this is the star and the “B” in BLT, you’ll want to use thick cut bacon for the most flavor and texture. You can cook this in a pan or make it in the oven!

  • Butter lettuce: A nice, tender lettuce that is mild in flavor is best for the “L”!

  • Large tomatoes: Heirlooms or beefsteak tomatoes are great for this!

  • Your favorite bread, sliced and toasted. The best bread to use for a BLT is sturdy, like whole wheat, rye, sourdough, or pumpernickel. Something that can bring some flavor and texture of its own to the table! Remember, we’re not making an average BLT here.

four BLTs being assembled with toast, homemade mayonnaise, bacon, lettuce and sliced tomato

How to Make the Best BLT

Luckily, the BLT is a fairly low maintenance sandwich, and very uncomplicated to make. Our favorite kind!

  1. Toast up your bread and spread a little homemade mayonnaise onto the inside of each slice.

  2. Stack a leaf of lettuce or two onto the bottom slice. Then weigh them down with the tomato slices. Last but not least, add your cooked, thick bacon (make sure it's good quality!). Top with the second slice of bread, mayo side down.

  3. Sink your teeth into your best homemade BLT yet!

two halves of a BLT with homemade mayonnaise stacked on top of each other next to a glass bowl of homemade mayonnaise

Tools You’ll Need

  • Toaster: You’ll need this to give your bread that satisfying crunch!

  • Cutting board

  • Serrated knife: You can use this for both your bread and your tomatoes.

  • Immersion blender: This will make whipping up that homemade mayonnaise a breeze!

  • Baking sheet: This is for the bacon! If you’re cooking it in the oven, you’ll also need parchment paper and paper towels.


What to Eat with Our BLT Recipe

Even the great BLT can always be made even better with a good side dish. Depending on your mood, whether it be sweet, briny, savory, or spicy, any of these are mouthwatering options!

Time for a BLT Bonanza

Whether you’re having people over or just trying to reinvigorate your weekday lunches, our BLT will not disappoint- that’s a promise. So get stacking, and show us what you got by tagging us over on @themodernproper or #themodernproper!

BLT with Homemade Mayonnaise

  • Serves: 4
  • Prep Time: 10 min
  • Cook Time: 20 min
  • Calories: 635

Ingredients

  • 1 cup Homemade Mayonnaise
  • 8 slices thick bacon, cooked
  • 4 leaves butter lettuce or other soft lettuce
  • 2 large tomatoes (such as Roma, beefsteak or heirloom), 1/2-inch sliced
  • 8 slices bread, toasted

Method

  1. Spread the mayonnaise on top of all 8 slices of toasted bread.

  2. On 4 slices of the toast place a lettuce leaf or two.. Then add the tomato slices on top of the lettuce.

  3. Lastly place 2 slices of cooked bacon on top of the tomatoes.

  4. Place the remaining 4 toasts mayonnaise side down on the bacon slices.

Nutrition Info

  • Per Serving
  • Amount
  • Calories 635
  • Protein 14 g
  • Carbohydrates 34 g
  • Total Fat 49 g
  • Dietary Fiber 5 g
  • Cholesterol 35 mg
  • sodium 682 mg
  • Total Sugars 5 g

BLT with Homemade Mayonnaise

Questions & Reviews

Join the discussion below.

or

    Any questions?

    Need to change up some ingredients? Unsure about a step in the method? Click the Ask a Question button above. We’re here for you.

  • Jenn

    Delicious BLT, loved the homemade mayo.

    Glad you liked it Jenn, we LOVE making homemade mayo. Really amps up sandwiches.