If you follow us on Instagram, then you know that we are both pretty obsessed with the art of preparing a cheese board for a party. At this point, I’ve done it so many times that I’ve got it down to a science!
So, without further ado, here’s how to build a perfect cheese platter. From which cheeses to choose, what to pair them with and how to arrange it all, I’ve got cheese platter ideas for every event and get-together. Whether it's holiday entertaining or just a Friday night with friends, here’s how to make the PERFECT cheese platter.
How To Make A Cheese Board, Step 1: Buy the Cheese!
For an impressive cheese board selection, go to a store with a good cheese counter, or maybe even to your local small, specialty cheese shop.
If you go to a specialty cheese shop or gourmet cheese counter, you’ll probably get help picking out your cheeses from a cheesemonger. A cheesemonger is someone whose job is to care for the cheeses themselves. (Dream job, basically). Artisanal cheeses need special care to stay ripe and perfect, so cheesemongers do the work of slicing and packing and storing them carefully.
Ask the cheesemonger what’s in season (yes, cheeses have seasons!) and ask for tastes! A good cheesemonger will want you to taste the cheeses to be sure that you’re picking cheeses you actually like. Lastly, have fun with it! Cheese shopping is quite possibly one of my favorite “errands” ever.
No cheesemonger nearby? No worries. I’ve got a few tricks that will have you in and out of any regular grocery store in a jiffy with the makings of an excellent cheese board.
Choose The Best Cheeses For A Cheese Board
I suggest buying three (and up to five) cheeses for a large cheese board for a party. When selecting cheeses, you have a few options. Pick a theme (like “goat’s milk” or “Alpine-style”) for the sake of comparison. Or, go for high-contrast and select a few wildly different cheeses for the sake of difference.
Consider your guests. Are you serving the board to adventurous eaters? Maybe spring for more pungent, washed-rind cheeses, or some “stinky” blues. Or maybe you’ll be serving the cheese board to a crowd you’re not sure about? Choose milder, safe, crowd-pleasing cheeses like good-quality goat cheese (everyone always seems to love Humboldt Fog), a nice hunk of Gruyère, and a mild, milky brie.
Here are five categories I usually try to include on my cheese platter:
- Soft cheeses: Brie, camembert, chèvre. Anything you can spread works great for this category.
- Semi-soft: Fontina, muenster or Gouda.
- Semi-firm: Manchego, Gruyère or Comté.
- Hard, aged cheeses: An aged cheddar or white cheddar is delicious, even a really high-quality Parmigiano-Reggiano can be lovely. Pro tip: pair that Parm with some fancy honey!
What Goes On A Cheese Platter: Key Elements
I think of the makings of cheese boards in terms of categories I want to include. Every cheese platter I make includes:
- Cheese! Three cheeses is usually enough, and the most I’ve ever done is five cheeses (that’s a BIG cheese board). Variety is KEY. Something hard, something soft, and something a little stinky or funky is my general rule, but I have been known to go off book. See above for more tips about choosing the cheeses.
- Charcuterie. Cured meats like prosciutto or salami are always a beautiful addition to a cheese platter. Include whatever kind you love.
- Something briny! I love cornichon pickles and castelvetrano olives most of all. Kalamatas are nice, too. I often opt for pitted olives for ease. If you use olives with pits, just be sure to include a small ramekin for pits.
- Crackers or good bread, like a sliced fresh baguette. A variety of crackers can be really beautiful, too. I like to offer something plain and something seedy, too.
- Fruit: Just a little something sweet! Dried fruit like apricots or tart cherries can be nice, or fresh fruit like grapes can look really abundant and pretty.
- Salty crunch: Nuts! I often include salted almonds or pistachios. If you’re on a tight budget, skip the nuts!
- Fancy finishes: These are the optional extras that really make your cheese platter shine. I love to serve nice jam, honey, chutney or a fancy mustard on the side or nestled into the middle of the board. When I really want to impress people, I add a brick of honeycomb to my platter, and go extra hard on buying good olives.
If you are on a budget, don’t fret! When I am feeling stressed about money, I will often swap in a relatively common cheese for one or two of the cheeses and simply slice it and arrange it nicely. Trader Joe’s often has great deals on “fancy” cheeses, too. Their goat cheese logs can go a long way in making a cheese platter look fancy on a budget. Your friends will be thrilled with whatever you can put together.
Choosing Charcuterie
For the meat portion of the cheese board (AKA the charcuterie) go with just one or two varieties. Typically, I start with classic salami (either sliced thin from the deli, or slightly thicker from a log), then add prosciutto or pancetta. Pro tip: At the deli counter, always ask for a specific number of slices vs ordering by the pound, that way you know you’re getting enough slices per person.
On a budget? Just use one type and have it sliced very thin. It looks beautiful this way!
Choosing Crackers and Breads
In the words of Oprah, “I LOVE BREAD.” And so, naturally, I seem to always have a good baguette lying around. I usually purchase them for dinner and there are often leftovers. If I’m making a cheese board, you know that crusty bread is going to make an appearance. Slice it up and serve it side by side with whatever crackers you have on hand. Generally, I assemble a board with a buttery cracker, a very thin, mild cracker, and a seedy, grainy cracker. Variety is the spice of life and also of cheese platters!
Cheese Boards: Perfect for Every Occasion
The best thing about making a cheese board is how perfect they are for every get together. Nope, scratch that. The best thing about a cheese board is that it is a PLATE FULL OF CHEESE. The second best thing about them is how versatile they are. I like to bring cheese platters to:
- Picnics!
- Holiday parties! It is the THE ultimate Christmas appetizer.
- Birthday parties! Anyone else rather have a hunk of cheese than a birthday cake? Just me? OK, moving on.
- Book club! I always call dibs on bringing the cheese plate.
- Girls night: Gotta have something to soak up the rosé.
- Play dates. Goldfish are fine for the kids, but grown-ups deserve cheese!
Basically, the long and the short of it is that a cheese platter is always a welcome addition to your get together. You can keep it simple or try your hand at making it fancy. I’ll teach you how!
Presentation Matters!
Now to put it all together! Pick out a board. This could be a cutting board (never plastic though, please!), a cheese platter, or even a few plates that you put next to each other on the table. Don’t be tied down to having to fit everything on one surface if you don’t have something large enough. When it comes to styling your cheese board, it doesn’t have to be perfect. The cheeses themselves are often so beautiful that the food does the work for you! Colorful fruit, emerald olives and rosy rounds of charcuterie; who could say that a spread like that isn’t a thing of beauty?!
If you don't have special cheese knives, it’s fine to cut thin pieces of cheese ahead of time, so your guests can just grab and go. Or, just use basic butter knives for folks to spread the soft cheeses.
Is It OK To Serve Room Temperature Cheese?
Yes! In fact, your cheeses will have a lot more flavor if you set them out for 30 minutes before serving it to your guests. Room temperature is THE ideal temperature for a cheese platter.
Tools You Will Need:
More Cheese Board Styling Ideas
Cheese, For One or All
For more recipe inspiration, follow us on Substack, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and Pinterest or order our cookbook. We love when you share your meals. Tag us on Instagram using #themodernproper. Happy cooking!